Thursday, February 20, 2014

Baseball America Top 100 Comparison

Here is the full list if you hadn't checked it out yet. If so, why are you here and not there? Haha..

I did a side by side comparison of my top 300 pro prospects to see how it stacks up against BA. I know I am more fond of certain prospects and this sheds some light on that.

At the top, I'm much higher on Lucas Giolito at 10, compared to 21 for BA. Albert Almora is at 12 for me, 36 for them. Clint Frazier at 19 compared to 48. A few other notables were Max Fried 21/53, Marcus Stroman 28/55, David Dahl 30/94, Dom Smith 36/92.

BA is much higher on Maikel Franco at 17 where I have him at 56. I'm low on Jameson Taillon 22/48, CJ Edwards 60/28, JOc Pederson 34/63, Kyle Zimmer 23/70, Aaron Sanchez 32/97, Kyle Crick 33/100, and Billy Hamilton 43/193.


Unique to their list
Billy Hamilton
Braden Shipley
Nick Kingham
Rafael Montero
Stephen Piscotty
Mookie Betts
Alen Hanson
J.P. Crawford
Hunter Renfroe
Rosell Herrera
Pierce Johnson
Trey Ball
Jorge Bonifacio
Marcus Semien
Taylor Lindsey
Zach Lee
Jimmy Nelson
James Paxton
Arismendy Alcantara


Unique to my list
A.J. Cole
Wilmer Flores
Daniel Vogelbach
Rob Kaminsky
Matt Barnes
Hak-Ju Lee
Hunter Harvey
Manny Banuelos
Josmil Pinto
Justin Williams
Justin Nicolino
Roberto Osuna
Franchy Cordero
Lewis Thorpe
Luiz Gohara
Ian Clarkin
Tyrone Taylor
Tommy Joseph
Delino Deshields Jr.
Andrew Susac
Jonathan Schoop
Luis Sardinas

I look forward to seeing how this stacks up in a few years.

2 comments:

Penny Parker said...

Thanks for doing these lists and comparisons Matt. I always enjoy reviewing them here and via Minor League Ball. You don't get enough credit. Thanks and keep up the good work.

Matt Garrioch said...

Thank you Penny

Post a Comment